But I can't seem to get the words over my lips. Why is that?!?
Let me explain, no there's not a man in my life. Let's make that clear first. No, what I'm referring to here is something that I hope I'm not the only one to have experienced.
I don't know how it is in the rest of asia, but in places like China, Taiwan and Japan displays of affections are rare, some would say, maybe even non-existent. Don't get me wrong, there was and still is a lot of love in my family but we just don't know how to bring ourselves to say it. At least I dont...
As a kid, growing up in an asian environment inside a larger Danish society, I would often be envious of my friends who often got hugs and affection from their parents. For a while I thought that my family and myself included were dysfunctional. My parents would never hug us kids and the words "I love you" were never uttered in our home. Why? you ask. Because it's just not common, it's not what we do.
I remember once asking my dad about it and he replied: I don't think there's a reason to say it all the time and make it trivial. The most important thing is how you feel about that person. He then proceeded to tell me that he loved me and I should never ever doubt that even if it meant him not saying it everyday.
After I grew up things have changed around the house. My dad seems to once in while be a little more affectionate with me and my siblings, maybe something he missed doing when we were younger? I don't know, but my mom is still the emotionally distant person she'd always been.
Even though things changed with my dad I feel like I haven't changed. Even my friends notice it: That I'm just not that big on bodily contact. Is this a piece of my childhood where I was "deprived" of physical affection? Even today I can't bring myself to say those words to anyone...well at least anyone living.
I have no doubt that my parents love me and my siblings. But looking at them today, my brother, who I was talking to, directly told me that he wasn't comfortable when I put my hand on his shoulder to emphasize point I was making. I think it's safe to conclude that the three of us are in the same boat when it comes to physical touch.
This is part of why I think the words "I love you" seem to have lost all meaning. They become trivial when people just utter them over and over without thinking. When sitting at a café and hearing a man talk to his wife and son over the phone, saying "I love you" at the end of the conversation and that he'll be home shortly, only to turn around and stick his tongue down his mistress' throat and a hand up her skirt.
I feel like I have something to give but I don't know how. I can't make my mind go over the fact that my grandparents need me to be more emotionally available at times. So I do what I know.
I make my grandmother a cup of coffee every afternon when she wakes up and give her a manicure from time to time. I shave my grandfathers head when his hair is too long or find that glucosamine and chondroithine online when his knees are hurting. I tweeze my mothers eyebrows and dye her hair to make her feel pretty. I clean my brothers ears for him when it's necessary. I help my dad out with minor secretarial work because I can. I'm trying to spend every moment with my sister when she's available to let her know I'm there and to show I care. I bake and make enormous amounts of desserts and baked goods to feed my family, because this is how I know how to do things. I feed and care for them.
I can't hug them, because my entire body just shuts down when I start thinking about it
I love them but I can't say those words... Just like my mom. She loves us and shows us in so many ways. Just not the ones that are considered "normal" in a society.
So I'll whisper it here, right now. Out into the big cyberspace because that's the only way I can say it.
...
15 comments:
Chi, that's a beautiful and well-said post about letting your family know how much you love them through your actions. I agree with you for the most part about the physical contact with my family. Sometimes I wondered if it was an Asian thing, but I have to wonder if it just FEELS odd to show affection once you've grown up. It's awkward for me to hug my family members, even my sister (yet it's so easy to give her a swift kick in the ass if I'm standing behind her - for fun of course!).
I admire how you do so much for your family, especially your grandparents. I'm sure they understand how much you care and love them through your simple actions. Actions speak louder than words. :)
I really love this post. I grew up like you in that aspect, except you have chosen to love them in your own way while I no longer speak to my family. I email my sister occasionally and that is it...when she came to the states, I made up an excuse to not meet up with her (the thought of hugging her or opening up my life to her was too weird to wrap my head around).
Well, your post is making me think twice about the way I'm living my life, so thank you.
i've thought about the same thing so many times and i'm so envious of my friends who have families who are so open and affectionate with one another. I know my family loves and cares aobut everyone but we seem to be at that distant point where no one even asks the other how their days went..i want the closeness of the hugs and kisses..i remember my grandpa once telling me as a child that affection was a sign of weakness which he didn't want, and only children were weak and therefore only children could be shown love. i guess it's just an asian thing ? i can't change the fact of how my family acts. even when i say i love you or try to give them a hug, the actions never reciprocated.
sorry this got kinda long, thanks for this though..i kind of thought it was just my family.
Haha, don't worry, it's way common among Asian families.
My dad once said "I love you" because he saw it on Everybody Loves Raymond (a sitcom, do you have it in Denmark?), anyway, he started giggling like a little girl after he said it. Yeah, no one ever says it anymore...
When I come to visit them, we greet eachother with "did you get fatter?" and mostly just awkwardness coz we can't huge or say "I missed you!" It almost feel like we should handshake or something...
And when I leave (because we live in different countries), we just go "Ok...bye then..."
So trust me, no displays of affection...but i think i prefer it that way... words really don't mean much to me anyway...so why say it when it gives you goosebumps?
You know what would be funny? If you just start saying "I love you" all of a sudden to your family! Just to see how they react! Maybe even throw in some hugs to freak em out? :P haha, that would be funny no?
This is such a lovely and insightful post Chi! I completely understand how you feel like your family is less affectionate than most. I think that's just how most Asian cultures are, they just express emotion in a different way. Personally, I think that my parents showed more affection than most Asian families, but we still don't openly say I love you. Obviously, we do love each other, but we don't feel the need to tell each other every waking moment. This isn't just Asian families though, I had a German friend who said the same exact thing about her parents.
It means so much to me that by airing some of the silly thoughts I have, I am able to reach out and touch someone else. This is part of why I blog.
At first I was hesitant of making too personal entries but I think I'll start making some more from now on. You guys inspire me.
Thank you ^^
thank you! I think my boyfriend may be feel like you do.He is from an asian family and I rarely,if ever, hear him say affectionate words to me.But he does make a point to do things that make me happy. I used to think that he just appreciated me but not greatly. Probably he feels no need to say the words when he can show me how much he cares. Thank you, it helps me understand his feelings better.
Thank you! your comment was so touching. Also love the music on your blog ~ please keep blogging.
there is nothing wrong with not being hugged so much by your loved especially when tradition dictates it. My dad is half chinese and he's like that. My mom isn't, we call it "lambing" here and that's when we hug and cuddle each other like i'm still a little girl even when til i'm in my twenties. The hardest part about being exposed to that kind of act is that when the person is gone, you'll miss it so badly it hurts. now that my mom is gone, i rely to my boyfriend to give me the occasional "lambing".
You are such a beautiful person inside and out, having to say I love you need not be dictated by practice. but when the words just have to get out of you... and when it does, i don't think you'll have a hard time saying it. :) and sometimes, actions speaks louder than words.
That was really beautiful! I love you, Chyi Chyi. Now come to China, and let me show it to you by feeding...
i enjoyed reading this post cuz this is how i feel too.
no hugs or i love u's in the family. i just dont hear them. but yet my cousin gets a hug and kiss and i love u every day from my aunt, my mom's sister, and so i always wondered why I never got affection either...
it made me sad really. and in a way i fear that i never knew what love felt like if i was never quite given any from the family.
even back in middle school, one of my best friends was like "omg i love you!!" cuz u kno, us girls do that. and u kno what i said? "thank you!" ..i didnt say "i love you too" or whatever, cuz i just wasnt accustomed to it. nobody ever said that to me and i had NO freakin clue how to react other than a thank you. so sad...
we all in the house do things to show that we care. or at least..just one or two...but those i love u words and hugs never come forth...and to be honest, if my parents started hugging me and saying i love u to me right now, i'd be SO WEIRDED OUT. I mean, sure its what i wanted...but from the BEGINNING. now if they do it, its like its almost..fake? or..forced..just..sooo out of the norm.
oops sorry long comment i gave ya there ^^()
hope to see more of ur posts :)
that's a really well written post. sometimes feeling it is enough...
aww Chi, I know what you mean! I never thought too much about it until I started going to an international school and noticed how western kids interacted with their parents. I definitely felt envious like you did. Funny though, it would almost feel odd for us to give each other a hug now that we've never had that kind of relationship.
This is a beautiful post, Chi. Thanks for sharing it with us. I am sure there are many other families just like your's, you are not dysfunctional! People show their love in different ways. There is nothing wrong with that. My fam & I are physically affectionate, as in it's normal to hug & kiss on the cheek. But we rarely ever say "I love you" out loud. That's just how it's been with us.
Hope you've reached some clarity on this since this post is from a couple weeks ago. I've been MIA from the blogging world, but I might be making a come-back LOL.
It's cultural thing with Asian parents. My parents weren't physically affectionate with hugs and saying 'I love you'. Neither was I. It did bother me that my folks didn't express them that way.
It wasn't until I joined a congregation back in 1994. A very large international church, members are fun, hug, and normal, and say I love you. It was hard for me to hug or say I love you to friends. But it became more natural over time. I had lots of practice (8 yrs in the church).
Today I married, and I have two children. It's so easy for me to tell them I love them and hug them. It would deprive them so much on an emotional level if I didn't. A hug from my son is the warmest feeling in the world. Touch connects people. A hug from me when he's acting out calms him, let's him know I'm not mad and I love him. When my 2.5yr tells me "I love you sooo much," you have no idea how much it's like magic.
When you give them to others, it makes feel good and feel taken care of. Physical contact of a hug is so warm. You wonder why babies need to be held and touch.
It's easier for me to tell my mom I love her. It's not so easy still for me to tell my dad or give him a hug. But I do tell him.
Post a Comment